Friday, September 30, 2016

Illinbucks

The first thought that came to my mind when I thought about the concept of Illinibucks was Illini Cash. Illini Cash is a convenient way for students at UIUC to make purchases through their I-card instead of cash or debit card. Illini Cash is accepted in various locations such as dining halls, campus recreation, restaurants specifically located on campus, and printing stations. However, in contrast to Illinibucks, the campus would not have to administer a pre-specified price because it would hold the same value as actual money.

Having to set a specific value on cutting in line, I had trouble thinking of a way to appropriately analyze the price of Illinibucks. With that being said, ways that Illinibucks could be used would be cutting in line for dining halls, room at libraries, career fair, sporting events, and registering for classes. One way that I thought about analyzing the prices was to administer surveys. In the survey students would be asked how they would use Illinibucks and how often they would use it. However, I felt that this was somewhat unrealistic because not many students would know how they would practically use Illinibucks and their guesses on the surveys would not serve as an accurate way to set prices and would be too costly. Another way that prices could be analyzed would be through having a “trial period” for Illinibucks. For a certain period of time, a set amount of Illinibucks will be given to all the students and we can keep track of where and how often they use their Illinibucks.

When setting the prices, balance is crucial in that we want the students be motivated to spend the Illinibucks while not making it accessible. If the prices were set too low, there would be no need for Illinibucks. Too many students would utilize it because demands would far outweigh the supply and there would essentially be another first come first serve situation. If the prices were set too high, not many students would be able to utilize it and many services would remain in the same first come first serve situation.

Personally, I would utilize Illinibucks towards educational purposes, specifically to sign up for classes. Being an incoming second semester Junior, there are a lot of classes I need and want to take before graduating. Being able to use Illinibucks would not only save a lot of time but allow me to maximize my education at UIUC as I’m not constrained to only take certain classes because of the capacity. Another way I would use Illinibucks would be at lines in career fairs. At the career fair, the more well-known companies have a long line and many times, I don’t end up having the time to speak to recruiters from all the companies I wanted to go to. Through Illinibucks, I will be able to maximize my time at the career fair and allow me to build the necessary connections to obtain a job in the future.

However, I know that different students have different preferences and not all students would want or need to use their Illinibucks towards their education. I could see many students using their Illinibucks towards recreational activities such as sporting events or music events. This would benefit the students in that there would be shorter waiting time and they would be able to get the seats that they want. In addition, Illinibucks would be very convenient for students who are in a rush as it can be used to cut in lines for dining halls and rooms for libraries.


Overall, I think that Illinibucks is a great and convenient idea, but it would be harder to administer a set price for it.   

2 comments:

  1. Since you brought up the issue of not being able to get into classes that you want to take, why do you think it is that these classes get over subscribed? Is there a way to increase supply? Are there incentives in place for the department to encourage that?

    Conversely, are there incentives that actually discourage adding to class capacity? For example, if you can't get into the classes you need you may have to stay an extra semester or two to complete your degree requirements. Since tuition is paid per semester, not per degree, you would end up paying more tuition that way. Do you think the institution might be inadvertently encouraging that outcome?

    If so, would a different payment scheme in tuition impact how the institution manages the class capacity issue?

    Getting back to Illinibucks, if there were certain classes that a lot of students wanted to take so used Illinibucks for those classes, would it provide information to the offering department about how large the excess demand is? Might that be useful in planning future offerings?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You bring up a very interesting point about usage data of the Illinibucks. Like you mentioned, I could see how many students using their Illinibucks to get into certain classes can offer departments information about classes that are high in demand.

      With that being said, I think there are a couple reasons why classes get over subscribed: well-known professor, required class for multiple majors, popular topic, favorable time and day of the class, or less time and effort requirement. A way to increase supply would be to add more time slots for each class.

      Perhaps an incentive could be that because there are more classes available and more students are taking the class within the department, their reputation and popularity would increase. This would result in more students enrolling in the major or department which could potential affect the number of employees hired in the department and how much they get paid. Conversely, an incentive that can discourage adding to class capacity would be the reason you mentioned in your response. Because our institution is heavily underfunded, I do believe that the institution might be encouraging this outcome of wanting students to stay on campus.

      Delete